PDA

View Full Version : 2400 Swedish Comp ( Need feedback on 2 lists)



kefkah
17-01-2013, 21:18
So there is a swedish comp tournament coming up and i have spiked it down to 2 list. Since its hard to ask for improvment withouth the Comp-system,im just gonna post the two diffrent lists, wich Comp at the same lvl, and ask wich seems better.

The first list is the one i was gonna take, but after finished it i made a revamp to fit in a hydra. The question is how god a hydra can be.

The original list

1 X Dark Elv Chariot 100 p -6

1 X Dark Elv Chariot 100 p -9

1 X Dark Elv Chariot 100 p - 9

1 X RPT 100 -4

1 X RBT 100 -6

core 638 p -28

6 x DR + Xbow + mu = 139 p -5

6 X DR + Xbow + mu = 139 p -7

17 Xbow + mu = 175 p -10

17 Corsairs + mu +banners+shortbows = 185 p -6

20 BG + FC +Murder banners + Soulrender 345p -20

DL + Peg, SDC, Shield, Sword of Ruin, armour of servitude (reg),
Dragonbane gem, Poition of foolhardines 294 -21

DL + Peg+ SDC +HA +Shield +Whip of agoin +Dragonhelm
Talismans of preservation + TOTS 300 p -28

Lvl 2 Death + Tome of Furion (extra-spell) +Lifetaker 180 p -23

Master + Bsb + Armour of Darkness + Halberd+luckstone
139 p -16


13 Komp 2396 p


Now the one with the hydra

1 X Dark Elv Chariot 100 p -6

1 X Dark Elv Chariot 100 p -9

1 X Hydra 175 p -40

1 X RPT 100 -4

1 X RBT 100 -6

core 602 p -19

6 x DR + + mu = 109 p -3

8 X DR + mu+ shield = 151 p -3

17 Xbow + mu = 175 p -10

22 warriors + FC + Banners of swiftness 184- 6

20 BG + FC +Murder banners + Soulrender 345p -20

DL + Dark steed, SDC, Shield, Sword of Ruin, 4reg,
Dragonbane gem, POFH 262 -12

DL + Dark steed+ SDC +HA +Shield +Whip of agoin +Dragonhelm
Talismans of preservation + TOTS 268 p -19

Lvl 2 dark + TOF +LF 180 p -17

Master + Bsb + Armour of Darkness + Halberd+luckstone +ironcures icon
144 p -16

13,2 Komp 2393 p

The diffrence is that mage have to pick Dark, both Dreadlord goes on a Dark steed, one less chariot and the dark riders lose the xbows. Both dreadlords goes in the Big Dark Rider unit for lookout-sirs and to charge around. And 22 spears instead of 17 corsairs.


Im a bit thorn in this, is the Hydra worth to lose Death magic and the pegasus mount + Shooting with Dark Riders?. Would love new eyes on this

MR. GRUMPY
19-01-2013, 19:16
I think the first list is way stronger and versatile. A hydra can only do so much and most armies will have some kind of answers for it, more so then those peg characters.

BattleofLund
21-01-2013, 19:35
So there is a swedish comp tournament coming up and i have spiked it down to 2 list. Since its hard to ask for improvment withouth the Comp-system,im just gonna post the two diffrent lists, wich Comp at the same lvl, and ask wich seems better.

The first list is the one i was gonna take, but after finished it i made a revamp to fit in a hydra. The question is how god a hydra can be.

Fact is, a Hydra can be pretty good. While I agree with Mr. Grumpy about the #1 list being better, it seems a bit lacking in ferocity. Question: is it possible you've paid points for the Crimson Death on your BG Tower Master? Soulrender is 10 points cheaper.
Also, what's the tournament? GothCon?

Halbeard
23-01-2013, 19:18
The only thing I use my hydra for, is to take the attention of the things that really matters. If you really want to have full use of it, I suggest you use them in pair. But I agree with above, and if I where you I would have stick with the first list. Good luck at the tournament!

kefkah
27-01-2013, 07:46
So played with both lists vs Wood Elves and dwarfs both times.

The first list performed way better vs wood elves cause of the mobility, the changes i made is off with 1 chariot, a block of 26 spears instead of corsairs and harpies, and changed setup on the lords. Im gonna do a revision when i get some time.

Yeah its for gothcon, ive pretty much been come lately and get loses on most tournies so i figure i have a list ready some months ahead so i can playtest it to death.

Thanks for the replies.

Edit: This thread is 100 % Swedish lol!

snyggejygge
27-01-2013, 08:27
First list looks tougher for any of my armies (VC & WoC)

MR. GRUMPY
01-02-2013, 20:53
How are the RBTs serving you? I only ever use mine (in HE) when I got magic to boost them up, but I guess their komp is ok at least and DE have a way stronger shooting phase overall of course.