Yeah, I know this seems very similar to other "28mm Inquisitor" threads, but there is a subtle difference. I am not asking for a value judgment as to which scale is better, as that has been done to death (and I don't care anyway, ALL my gaming in the 40K universe is done in 15mm).
Rather, my question is would Inquisitor have been more likely to survive beyond the afterlife known as Specialist Games if it HAD been in the dominant GW scale?
I can see counter-arguments, and they are plentiful: GW tanks its games after a certain period anyway; the Inquisitor rules were too eclectic to catch a mass market; Inquisitor was not sure whether it wanted to be a wargame or an RPG, etc. However, I believe that it is an interesting niche game, and that [REMEMBER HATAS, THIS IS NOT A VALUE JUDGMENT] 54mm was a marketing blunder, when there was already a massive overload of 28mm stuff on the market in the exact same genre.
YMMV, I'd love to hear opposing views.