Page 5 of 24 FirstFirst ... 3 4 5 6 7 15 ... LastLast
Results 81 to 100 of 467

Thread: Warriors of Chaos rumours

  1. #81
    Chapter Master Son of Sanguinius's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Chatsworth, California
    Posts
    2,919

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Odin View Post
    Yes, there are a number of very good reasons in fact.

    a) They have always been a core part of the Chaos army

    b) Warriors are not the elite infantry, chosen are. Much like Saurus and Temple Guard in the case of Lizardmen.

    c) WoC as an army do not have the variety of toys that those other armies have - they are all about the infantry.

    d) Warriors are far from the best infantry in the game, point-for-point

    ... etc.
    a) So? It doesn't matter if they've always been that way. The paradigm is different.
    b) Warriors of chaos are elite infantry. Profiles and equipment dictate this. It's not my opinion.
    c) toys? I think with marks, gifts, eotg, three types of elite infantry, and three magic lores, they are very unique
    d) I will concede that this is mostly a matter of opinion, but it doesn't change their status as elite infantry.

    Quote Originally Posted by Gradek View Post
    Would you like some cheese with your whine. Seriously, warriors have been core since I started playing in 1994 and they have always been both elite and core. That is the WoC schtick after all. If you make them special or decrease the stat line, you might as well not bother with WoC anymore and change it to Marauders of Chaos. Just be thankful that knights aren't core anymore like when I started.
    Unnecessary to be snide.

    I very much would like to field warriors as core but the fact is "it's always been that way" is notan argument with any weight.
    The Arena of Death, where I write the duel you imagine.

    The Coming Apocalyse, my blog for 40k and FB rules development.

  2. #82

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Son of Sanguinius View Post
    I very much would like to field warriors as core but the fact is "it's always been that way" is notan argument with any weight.
    But it is a good argument when one looks at the other special choices. GW are in the business to sell minis and moving warriors to special will sell less minis, not more. Who exactly is going to buy special warrior minis, when we already have knights, trolls, DO's, Ogres, and chariots as special (I am assuming you would advocate chosen to rare, which is also ludicrous since the only thing that makes them good is FoTG and an absurdly expensive combo with the Wailing Banner and 2 warshrines).

    If I were a betting man, I would say warriors not only remain core, but actually come down in cost a point or 2 with no stat line changes, but that FoTG either gets removed or nerfed (ie no re-rolling when you can have a viable result).

  3. #83
    Commander iamjack42's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2008
    Location
    Virginia, USA
    Posts
    578

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Son of Sanguinius View Post
    I very much would like to field warriors as core but the fact is "it's always been that way" is notan argument with any weight.
    I agree. I support dwarfs with M8 and Elves with T5. Just because they didn't used to be that way is not an argument with any weight.

    Furthermore, I think we need to take Knights out of Brettonian core. Their profile and equipment dictate that they are elite. 35% Men at Arms and Bowmen!

  4. #84
    Librarian
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Langley, BC, Canada
    Posts
    446

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Ogre's are pretty elite, I think all they should get are gnoblars for core.

  5. #85
    Chapter Master Son of Sanguinius's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Chatsworth, California
    Posts
    2,919

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Gradek View Post
    But it is a good argument when one looks at the other special choices. GW are in the business to sell minis and moving warriors to special will sell less minis, not more. Who exactly is going to buy special warrior minis, when we already have knights, trolls, DO's, Ogres, and chariots as special (I am assuming you would advocate chosen to rare, which is also ludicrous since the only thing that makes them good is FoTG and an absurdly expensive combo with the Wailing Banner and 2 warshrines).

    If I were a betting man, I would say warriors not only remain core, but actually come down in cost a point or 2 with no stat line changes, but that FoTG either gets removed or nerfed (ie no re-rolling when you can have a viable result).
    I agree that they will likely stay as core. But chosen being mediocre or bad is an entirely different issue, as are the other special choices. We should not begrudge a situation of many suitable options for special choices.

    Quote Originally Posted by iamjack42 View Post
    I agree. I support dwarfs with M8 and Elves with T5. Just because they didn't used to be that way is not an argument with any weight.

    Furthermore, I think we need to take Knights out of Brettonian core. Their profile and equipment dictate that they are elite. 35% Men at Arms and Bowmen!
    What is with these frivolous comments? I'm trying to discuss WoC rumors here, not marvel at how witty you think you are.
    The Arena of Death, where I write the duel you imagine.

    The Coming Apocalyse, my blog for 40k and FB rules development.

  6. #86
    Librarian
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Langley, BC, Canada
    Posts
    446

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    The fact is that an army called Warriors of Chaos will have a troop of similar name (Chaos Warriors) as a core unit. Just like how Ogres have Ogres as core, and Orcs and Goblins have Orcs, and Goblins. The fact that Chaos Warriors are elite is not going to change. Neither is their core status. Elite or not, it's what set's the army apart from others. Do you really want WoC to be empire without cannons and less choices for their ****** hordes?

  7. #87
    Chapter Master Son of Sanguinius's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Chatsworth, California
    Posts
    2,919

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    The empire doesn't require cannons to be core and is a prime example of how the name means nothing in regards to your point, as are tomb kings and vampire counts.
    The Arena of Death, where I write the duel you imagine.

    The Coming Apocalyse, my blog for 40k and FB rules development.

  8. #88

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Not trying to offend or anything but I hope you are not trolling or being intentionally obtuse. Warriors of chaos have been since forever an elite army. Elite. That means an army of small numbers but superior stats. They are not a horde army so comparisons with orcs, undead don't really make sense. Neither can they go gunline style like the empire. An army with little to no shooting has to either have very good stats to survive getting to close combat, or be numerous enough to not care about losses. Warriors of chaos are the former. Whatever your opinion is this is the idea behind the army. They are close combat specialists.
    Quote Originally Posted by philbrad2 View Post
    You've hit the nail on the head.... "Codex:CSM - The margarine of evil, the diet Coke of evil, just 1 calorie ... not evil enough!"
    Quote Originally Posted by IcedCrow View Post
    Scenario - Lulz
    Special Rules - One player only needs to score 1/4 of the scenario points value to win. Roll a D6 or punch your opponent in the face. Whoever rolls highest OR bleeds the most gets to pick. The winner may wear the fabled Belt of Win and gets his face on the cover of White Dwarf.

  9. #89

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Well since everyone is blicking about Warriors, the old models are in need of a re-sculpt since conversion wise they are terrible. Hopefully their be redone like the knights, same goes for the marauders (which aren't as bad).

  10. #90
    Chapter Master logan054's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Colchester, uk
    Posts
    7,195

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Son of Sanguinius View Post
    I agree with the sentiment, but you could justify the same idea for any army. A paranoid Elector Count who trains vast amounts of Greatswords. A venerable Slann Mage-Priest with a vast Temple Guard force. A Black Orc Warboss who doesn't trust pale greenskins. No one else gets to have their elite infantry as Core and there is no justification for why Warriors of Chaos should get to alone. Especially when they are one of the game's finest elite infantry.
    Jesus, don't you think they have screwed over the chaos players enough, they already took daemons and beasts out of the army, now you want to move chaos warriors to special? because its fair? why is fair that elves are M5? humans don't have it, why is it fair dwarfs have M3, humans don't have it, why is is fair orcs can take big uns as core? maybe space marines are to good to be troops, perhaps scouts should be the only troop choice, few other armies have troops choices with stats like that, how can that be (I'm a marine player btw) It all sounds abit silly doesn't it, fact is chaos warriors don't need justification, its a warriors of chaos army and not a Marauders of chaos army! like I said, I don't want a army of empire swordsman on big bases, I want a army of chaos warriors as was sold to me through repeated army books.

    Quote Originally Posted by Deaf Paradox View Post
    Well since everyone is blicking about Warriors, the old models are in need of a re-sculpt since conversion wise they are terrible. Hopefully their be redone like the knights, same goes for the marauders (which aren't as bad).
    The chaos warriors are fine for conversion, you make some pretty damn cool chaos warriors with great weapons using the chaos knight weapons and heads, I happen to love the chaos warrior models, I would hate them to look like the current chaos knights, the only parts I like about them is the weapons, heads and horses.
    Last edited by logan054; 30-01-2012 at 20:08.

  11. #91
    Chapter Master Son of Sanguinius's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Chatsworth, California
    Posts
    2,919

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    I am neither trolling nor being obtuse, and thank you for attempting at civility. I am debating the point that chaos warriors should be a special choice, and in doing so I am trying to point out what I see as argument flaws by using contradicting evidence or by proposing that familiarity isn't philosophical justification. I don't see how this warrants being treated as a contrarion, outside of frustrated reactions to someone who doesn't agree with you.

    Now, to your point about them being cc specialists, I totally agree. But how does this identity suffer with a move to special? Moreover, orcs find cc just as important and do not have black orcs as core. I'm not suggesting WoC be mirrors of the orcs, but with all the background on immense invasions every few hundred years, there is, at the very least, the suggestion that marauders are the core of the army. No pun intended.
    The Arena of Death, where I write the duel you imagine.

    The Coming Apocalyse, my blog for 40k and FB rules development.

  12. #92
    Chapter Master Rosstifer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Tauranga, New Zealand.
    Posts
    1,670

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Just as an issue of cost, do you realise how many Marauders people would have to buy to fill up core? You'd need over a hundred kitted Marauders to reach the 600pts in a 2400pt game. Two units of 18 Chaos Warriors fills up the same amount of Core. Marauders are 20 quid a pop in the UK, the cheapest place to buy GW. You'd need 8 boxes or so. That's 160GBP, assuming you want to use the old models and not conversions, which would be even more restrictive. 160GBP for just the core could stop a lot of people from even being able to play the army.
    Currently working on - The Blood Herd of Vorgoth (Beastmen)

    Rankings - 3rd in New Zealand, Best General - Warriors of Chaos (And that's enough vanity for now....)

    Currently Listening to (Keeping me sane whilst painting) - Deuce - Nine Lives

  13. #93

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Deaf Paradox View Post
    Well since everyone is blicking about Warriors, the old models are in need of a re-sculpt since conversion wise they are terrible. Hopefully their be redone like the knights, same goes for the marauders (which aren't as bad).
    Avatars of War is releasing Chaos Warriors which are pretty nice and have various options.

  14. #94
    Chapter Master Morkash's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Salzburg
    Posts
    1,763

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Chaos Warriors will stay Core with almost 100% certainty. There is no reason whatsoever from GW's point of view to move them to Special. And while you present your opinion quite well, Son of Sanguinius, it remains your opinion and not something which has to change because of their apparent superior stats or something else. You are not neutral on this matter, and neither am I or many others here.
    When you read the Designer's Notes for the current AB you will see that Phil Kelly gave the Chaos Warriors Chaos Armour intentionally to allow players to take a whole army clad in hellforged Armour, which would be small but very elitary. I think we will see mostly point adjustments in the Core section, Marauders one point up, CW one point down. Something along these lines, I do not see any major changes to be honest.

    What would interest me are GW's plans with the Chosen and Eye of the Gods in general. Right now the latter is usually only used when abused by the former. Which is a shame, because it is a very characterful rule! For the Chosen, I do not know what could change...maybe more god-specific options to underline their status as, well, Chosen?
    Look upon us and Despair, for we are the End, the Decay of all things, the horror of rot and the blessing of plague.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lord Damocles View Post
    There's your problem. One person's 'sensible and popular' is another person's Codex: Grey Knights.

  15. #95

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by logan054 View Post
    The chaos warriors are fine for conversion, you make some pretty damn cool chaos warriors with great weapons using the chaos knight weapons and heads, I happen to love the chaos warrior models, I would hate them to look like the current chaos knights, the only parts I like about them is the weapons, heads and horses.
    I just wish that the model had more poses than the one trick pony it is, having the model so the legs and torso were seperate with the ability to add the cloak on would make the Chao Warriors kit so much more versatile and interesting.

    Quote Originally Posted by lbecks View Post
    Avatars of War is releasing Chaos Warriors which are pretty nice and have various options.
    I have seen a picture of them somewhere in wip and they look amazing, hopefully this will edge GWS to do something dynamic of their own.

  16. #96

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    I have a few ideas what change would be in Warriors of Chaos:
    Hero who will be Marauder, not Exalted - he will be cheaper and enough against many armies
    Chaos Knights - champion with magic item up to 25 points, as it's in other heavy cavalry
    Spawn special, Chosen rare and 0-1 (fluff)

  17. #97
    Chapter Master Odin's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Greenwich
    Posts
    5,086

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Son of Sanguinius View Post
    c) toys? I think with marks, gifts, eotg, three types of elite infantry, and three magic lores, they are very unique
    I think you missed the point. Uniqueness is not the issue. The issue is that WoC do not have a huge variety of support for their elite infantry. If they had access to handgunners, cheap mortars and steam tanks then yes, Warriors as core might be overpowered. If they had Slann Mage Priests, Terradons and Skinks, likewise. But they don't - they pretty much just have combat infantry, combat cavalry, combat monstrous infantry and combat monsters (yes, there is also the hellcannon). The weakness of flexibility is offset against the benefit of elite infantry in Core.

    I would be very surprised if basic warriors don't come down a point or two. If they are no longer core I will eat my hat. And then sell my WoC army.

  18. #98

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Rosstifer View Post
    Just as an issue of cost, do you realise how many Marauders people would have to buy to fill up core? You'd need over a hundred kitted Marauders to reach the 600pts in a 2400pt game. Two units of 18 Chaos Warriors fills up the same amount of Core. Marauders are 20 quid a pop in the UK, the cheapest place to buy GW. You'd need 8 boxes or so. That's 160GBP, assuming you want to use the old models and not conversions, which would be even more restrictive. 160GBP for just the core could stop a lot of people from even being able to play the army.
    Shhhhh if anyone at GW reads this Chaos Warriors will move to special for sure! Anyway back to discussing the rumours, what worries me is that nothing has been heard about a new chariot model. Please don't tell me it will stay as is. A thought occured to me that maybe there will be a chariot / warshrine dual kit, but then again if the warshrine model has god specific bits to personalize it a bit then I don't know how everything can fit in one box.
    Quote Originally Posted by philbrad2 View Post
    You've hit the nail on the head.... "Codex:CSM - The margarine of evil, the diet Coke of evil, just 1 calorie ... not evil enough!"
    Quote Originally Posted by IcedCrow View Post
    Scenario - Lulz
    Special Rules - One player only needs to score 1/4 of the scenario points value to win. Roll a D6 or punch your opponent in the face. Whoever rolls highest OR bleeds the most gets to pick. The winner may wear the fabled Belt of Win and gets his face on the cover of White Dwarf.

  19. #99
    Chapter Master logan054's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Colchester, uk
    Posts
    7,195

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Deaf Paradox View Post
    I just wish that the model had more poses than the one trick pony it is, having the model so the legs and torso were seperate with the ability to add the cloak on would make the Chao Warriors kit so much more versatile and interesting.
    Its funny because all these multi part models still end up being in pretty much the same pose so they all rank up!

  20. #100

    Re: Warriors of Chaos rumours

    Quote Originally Posted by Odin View Post
    I think you missed the point. Uniqueness is not the issue. The issue is that WoC do not have a huge variety of support for their elite infantry. If they had access to handgunners, cheap mortars and steam tanks then yes, Warriors as core might be overpowered. If they had Slann Mage Priests, Terradons and Skinks, likewise. But they don't - they pretty much just have combat infantry, combat cavalry, combat monstrous infantry and combat monsters (yes, there is also the hellcannon). The weakness of flexibility is offset against the benefit of elite infantry in Core.

    I would be very surprised if basic warriors don't come down a point or two. If they are no longer core I will eat my hat. And then sell my WoC army.
    cheaper warriors.. I hope not!
    How about going back to one attack per warrior and lower the points. So chosen have 2 attacks and differ more?

    In the fluff most of the chaos forces are marauders and beastman with a few chaos warriors, so it's fuffy that they become special.But I also don't think that will happen.

Page 5 of 24 FirstFirst ... 3 4 5 6 7 15 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •