
Originally Posted by
Whut
If you think its a great model, buy it, paint it, and display it. Or use it as a basic captain. Only play things if they are good to play.
If you want great fluff, read books, there is no reason to include bad things in your list.
Yes. 100% no reason to take him. He costs more than twice the points of a captain, with no save of any kind, and the same profile. He has a basic longbow which does D3 wounds against monsters, and always wounds them on a 4+. They still get their full armor save.
His huntsman are 37% more expensive, and gain a rule that makes them ItP (but who cares because anything that hits them in combat will wipe them anyway, regardless of fear/terror) and a rule that lets them reroll to hit against monsters. With BS3 and S3 bows. So.... in effect they are worthless against monsters anyway.
So yes, there is no point in taking him.
Sad, because if he instead gave all of his huntsmen a similar ability to his own bow, he would be worth it to take at least in fluffy games. I support use of fluffy lists unless something is just SO HORRIBLY BAD that there is zero point in including it in your list.