Results 1 to 17 of 17

Thread: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

  1. #1
    Commander knightime98's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Tampa, United States
    Posts
    907

    Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    I was perusing the new Empire book and looking to see if a unit of State Troops could take a magic banner.
    I don't see it anywhere? I thought that someone had said that a single unit of State Troops were allowed to take a 50pt banner. However, I don't see it listed anywhere. I do see that all the Special units can take a magic banner (abundantly).

    Any help with a page number on this one would be great. But as far as I can tell at this point it looks as if State Troops lost out big on this issue.
    Check out my Podcast for Warhammer Fantasy

    www.nordlander.us

  2. #2
    Librarian stainawarjar's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Norway
    Posts
    492

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Yep, state troops can no longer take a magic banner. Like most basic infantry in the game.
    Quote Originally Posted by x-esiv-4c View Post
    Remember, Neck-bearded Howlers have to be dealt with like misbehaving dogs or feral hobos. Wack 'em with a rolled up newspaper and shout "NO. WE DON'T DO THAT INSIDE. NOOOOO"
    The big frog leading the lizardmen is called a "Slann" not a "Slaan", the big bird in the Empire is called a "Griffon" not a "Gryphon". The Bretonnian bird is, unfortunately, called a hippogryph.

  3. #3

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    However Greatswords can now have a magic banner without this rule, so you still have a state troop with a magic banner (but not a core one)

  4. #4

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    I think only 4 unit types can take magic banners now, IC Knights, Reiksguard, GS and Demigryphs. Be interesting to see how that matches up with the other 8e army books.
    Free your hobby! Be creative and stop slavishly following the damn Book.
    Quote Originally Posted by Osbad View Post
    Anyone calling the LotR system's balance inferior to the other 2 core games' is just spouting absolute rubbish and clearly doesn't know what they are talking about.
    RIP Brimstone.
    I used to read the GW Other Forum, but I am much happier now.

  5. #5
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Posts
    614

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Way more than Orcs, way more than Vc, way more than Ogres and way more than Tomb Kings.

  6. #6

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    It seems magical standard are indeed becoming rarer in armies. Bob and his halberdier Buddies from the 117th regiment of Altdorf will not be important enough to carry one.
    Its probably a trend.
    Bretonnians ARE NOT a pure Knightly army.
    Half the army choices consist out of Peasants and Damsels.
    'Pride cometh before a choppa in the face'

  7. #7

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Quote Originally Posted by EDMM View Post
    Way more than Orcs, way more than Vc, way more than Ogres and way more than Tomb Kings.
    A little more detail please? "Way more" seems a little interpretive
    Free your hobby! Be creative and stop slavishly following the damn Book.
    Quote Originally Posted by Osbad View Post
    Anyone calling the LotR system's balance inferior to the other 2 core games' is just spouting absolute rubbish and clearly doesn't know what they are talking about.
    RIP Brimstone.
    I used to read the GW Other Forum, but I am much happier now.

  8. #8
    Veteran Sergeant jonadaya's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    96

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Tomb kings: 2 (one unit of chariots and tomb guards) Orcs: 4 (big uns, black orcs, boar riders, savage boar riders) Vampires : 4 (one unit of skeletons, grave guards, black knights, knights of the blood keep) Ogres : 3 (one unit of Iron guts, maneaters, mournfang.)
    Quote Originally Posted by Jolly Puggles View Post
    It's bad enough that Skaven are bringing portable altars and Dwarves are carting mobile forges without Vampires bringing their palace furniture too! What's next, the Bretonnian "Bath-Tub-Of-Doom" or the mighty High Elf "Conservatory of Magic-ness"?

  9. #9

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    One comment for the orcs, Savage Orc Big Uns cant take a standard (not the boar variant).
    Bretonnians ARE NOT a pure Knightly army.
    Half the army choices consist out of Peasants and Damsels.
    'Pride cometh before a choppa in the face'

  10. #10

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Quote Originally Posted by Artinam View Post
    One comment for the orcs, Savage Orc Big Uns cant take a standard (not the boar variant).
    A lot of people seem to miss this.

  11. #11

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Who cares if there are 4, 3 or 2? There's no many interesting Magic Standards. THe flaming one, the armour piercing one, and the +1 Leadership.....and with empire, you have the repeat 1's on charge too.
    Quote Originally Posted by djhowitzer View Post
    we all play toy soldiers as a hobby. what on earth makes you think we can manage adult discussions?
    Quote Originally Posted by RandomThoughts View Post
    A good driver with a Volkswagon can beat a bad driver with a Ferrari if their race track is curvy and hard to maneuver, but will lose to another driver of equal skill with a better car. That's all I have to say on that issue.

  12. #12

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    I must concur... not a whole ot of thrilling magic standards left anyways...

  13. #13
    Commander knightime98's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Tampa, United States
    Posts
    907

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Quote Originally Posted by yabbadabba View Post
    I think only 4 unit types can take magic banners now, IC Knights, Reiksguard, GS and Demigryphs. Be interesting to see how that matches up with the other 8e army books.
    Which is very sad to me, because I play with a ton of core infantry. I don't use knights very often if at all much less the new Demigryphons. I think this part of it is a very sore loss for me.
    Check out my Podcast for Warhammer Fantasy

    www.nordlander.us

  14. #14
    Librarian
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Germany
    Posts
    372

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Quote Originally Posted by ihavetoomuchminis View Post
    Who cares if there are 4, 3 or 2? There's no many interesting Magic Standards. THe flaming one, the armour piercing one, and the +1 Leadership.....and with empire, you have the repeat 1's on charge too.
    That's not true - Skaven would love it to take more banners than their allowed 2 (one unit of plague monks and one unit of stormvermin). Stormbanner, flaming banner, banner of discipline, banner of the underempire, armour piercing banner ... I love my High elves for this that they can take more than 3 magic banners ...

  15. #15

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Quote Originally Posted by knightime98 View Post
    Which is very sad to me, because I play with a ton of core infantry. I don't use knights very often if at all much less the new Demigryphons. I think this part of it is a very sore loss for me.
    I think you have only lost flexibility, possibly one additional magical banner in your army, that's it.
    Free your hobby! Be creative and stop slavishly following the damn Book.
    Quote Originally Posted by Osbad View Post
    Anyone calling the LotR system's balance inferior to the other 2 core games' is just spouting absolute rubbish and clearly doesn't know what they are talking about.
    RIP Brimstone.
    I used to read the GW Other Forum, but I am much happier now.

  16. #16

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    Quote Originally Posted by BlackPawl View Post
    That's not true - Skaven would love it to take more banners than their allowed 2 (one unit of plague monks and one unit of stormvermin). Stormbanner, flaming banner, banner of discipline, banner of the underempire, armour piercing banner ... I love my High elves for this that they can take more than 3 magic banners ...

    True...but i was talking only about the books released in 8th edition
    Quote Originally Posted by djhowitzer View Post
    we all play toy soldiers as a hobby. what on earth makes you think we can manage adult discussions?
    Quote Originally Posted by RandomThoughts View Post
    A good driver with a Volkswagon can beat a bad driver with a Ferrari if their race track is curvy and hard to maneuver, but will lose to another driver of equal skill with a better car. That's all I have to say on that issue.

  17. #17
    Commander DivineVisitor's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Location
    Dundee, Scotland
    Posts
    598

    Re: Heirloom rule for General of the Empire removed? Was it replaced ?

    I used to take the Flaming Banner alot but now that Warrior Priests can grant flaming attacks i haven't bothered with it.

    The banner i use most though is the Ranger Standard as i have a habit of using a big block of Knights and it's useful being able to charge through various terrain without having to worry that 1/6th or 1/3rd of the unit are gonna take a dive.
    Space Wolves - Alpha Legion - Biel Tan - Empire - Lizardmen - Slaaneshi Daemons

    - Sona Mi Areru Ec Sancitu -
    - Art Thou The Holy One -

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •