Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3
Results 41 to 59 of 59

Thread: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

  1. #41
    Chapter Master stormblade's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Holy Terra
    Posts
    1,321

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Not that the opposite was implied by the question.
    Last edited by stormblade; 26-05-2012 at 12:53.
    "WE ARE THE ONLY SOURCE OF GOODNESS, SEVERE AND DRASTIC. THERE IS NO OTHER SOURCE OF HOPE THAN US. WE ARE AGONISINGLY ALONE."
    beer and axes

  2. #42
    Veteran Sergeant flota's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Location
    México
    Posts
    113
    Quote Originally Posted by Erikjust View Post
    Xavier: Being paralyzed from the waist down he probably wouldnīt be much use as a Librarian (havenīt read anywhere of marines that have their spinal cords severed somehow being able to walk again) so he would either be an Astropath or working alongside Jean as an interrogator.
    Ravenor


    sent from holy Terra using jokersax11 CM9 atrix ICS build

  3. #43

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by Askil the Undecided View Post
    The Emperor purposely infused the powers of the warp into the Primarchs to make them superior to anything else around (even to the point of giving himself a run for his money.) The space marines on the other hand are not psychically gifted in this manner, they are just given extra moist meaty chunks (20 of them in fact) the fact that all humans in 40k are inherently psychic and that upon induction to a legion/chapter they are hypno-indoctrinated makes them manifest weird phenomena regarding their primarch.
    Codex Imperialis (2nd ed) actually implied that space marines inherit a (small) degree of their Primarchs' warp-enhanced strength.

    edit: oh and in 40k Xavier would be in a dread' :P
    Sent from my Astropath using Tele Talk

  4. #44
    Chapter Master TheDungen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2012
    Location
    The Frozen North
    Posts
    3,278

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Please folks lets not forget the old saying:


    "kill the mutant! burn the heretic! purge the unclean!"

    I think Wolverine and co is considered mutants? I wouldnt want to be them if the space marines show up, even if they managed to kill of the vanguard the SM would rather conduct and extermintus than let such powerful mutants get away, and i doubt even Jean Grey could hold that back for long.


    Jokes aside no Space Marines arent based on Captain america, i dont think the comic captain america was very common in the UK when the space marines were created.
    In fact i've never seen it anywhere in europe, its nearly seen as much as a joke as Thor is here in sweden, suprisngly good movie though (Captain America that is the Thor movie was even worse than i thought it was, if Bifrost ended up in nevada why are the norse gods worshipped in northern europe? Why did Thor suddenly go from spoiled and prideful to all noble and stuff? The earlier behaviours was just being upset about not getting laid or what?).

  5. #45
    Chapter Master Col. Tartleton's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    3,568

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by GodlessM View Post
    Good to see I'm not the only one that realises Cap predates GW Space Marines by more than 4 decades.



    No she really couldn't. Average car weighs 1000kg. The strongest man in the world under stress (i.e. with adrenaline already pumping through him) can lift 395kg. I tihink you can see what I'm getting at here. Simply put, adrenaline can only do so much, the ability has to exist in the first place.
    I'm not suggesting she lifted a car over her head and threw it... and it's not really the adrenaline, as I'm sure you know it's the musculature pulling properly. Human muscles only use a fraction of their strength at any time. When your arms are tired lifting weight they shake. That's different motor groups in the muscles firing off in turn to maintain power without straining too much. In an emergency your body can pull with all the muscle groups in which case you get some superhuman strength. The reason we usually can't do this is that you risk pulling your muscles off your bones and the body won't let you. One of the fastest wide receivers at my high school escaped the police on foot running down a road they were following him in cars down. He had to be running over 20 mph and he's no Usain Bolt. People are physically capable of reaching around 40mph. Humans "in the wild" would be able to hold their own with African fauna.

  6. #46
    Chapter Master El_Machinae's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    a pale blue dot
    Posts
    3,354

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    You're talking about inhibition of the Golgi Tendon!

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autogen...ibition_reflex
    Pro-actively transhumanist and an Immortalist
    The fable of the dragon tyrant explains why. Text. Youtube.
    You and I have opportunity to create synergy

  7. #47

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by Askil the Undecided View Post
    Nothing, it's imaginary. Just a word made up
    The dismaying part is that you have a concept that you can't figure out anything to do with. It is like saying that phlogiston is a worthless idea because the modern understanding of combustion has better explanatory power. Hey: that just means that it has less explanatory power; it has some power, just not as much. It's possible to talk intelligibly about phlogiston, and to use it in a chemical equation as the negative of some number of oxygens.

    When you read the word soul, you know what it means, even if you think it is an outmoded concept.

    In 40k however the soul is the warp reflection of the individual, it is the reflection of the energy an individual expresses reflected in a realm of pure energy.
    Yeah, it reflects the actions and potency of an individual. It is affected by events in the materium, so that when a person contacts suffering or greed his soul may respond, and when he becomes stronger or weaker, his soul reflects strength or weakness. When a soul is pumped full of energy, it can correlate with an improvement in physical or mental ability, or it can burst out in unnatural psychic display. Except for the last case, the warp does not actually have to exist.

    Eldar are long lived, physically superior to humans, and their souls are strong. Tau have natural life spans shorter than humans', they can only do the jobs they are born into, and their souls are feeble. A person's soul is what he is, so adding to his body adds to his soul. Grafting organs with another person's genes onto a person's body, to the extent that a space marine is completely different from the person he would have been without those organs, means his life and his soul, whatever life he would have led on Fenris or Deliverance, are effectively overwritten by the significance of those organs. The space marine is an armature that holds up an occulobe and a biscopea, a substrate for the power of marine zygotes to make their mark in the world. A primarch's dna is doing the work, the aspirant is an amenuensis for a greater man.

  8. #48
    Commander Private_SeeD's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    Land of the sheep, and no not New Zealand
    Posts
    845
    Xavier wasn't born paralysed, but in 40k they could give him a pair of bionics for that, so he'd either be a crazy powerful liberian or be working for one of the ordo's like Ravenor, but the others would have issues when their being selected cause all recruits get screened and I'm sure they'd pick up on their DNA anomalies. Going back to the OP I think Cap A would have of a SM scout minus all the other crazy organs



    Sent from my Omni tool via the Sol System Mass Relay
    "Mia clementia, denar esto" - "Have mercy. I was blind, but now I can see"
    A can of Inferno Relentless a day, keeps the doctor at bay
    Quote Originally Posted by Sir_Turalyon View Post
    The Descent of Angels would be good if titled "Cyphers favorite childhood memories"
    Quote Originally Posted by Vote Kantor View Post
    You are all forgetting the two unknown primarchs, chuck norris and santa

  9. #49
    Chapter Master Askil the Undecided's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Shoreham, West Sussex, UK
    Posts
    1,867

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by Orthodox View Post
    When you read the word soul, you know what it means, even if you think it is an outmoded concept.

    Yeah, it reflects the actions and potency of an individual. It is affected by events in the materium, so that when a person contacts suffering or greed his soul may respond, and when he becomes stronger or weaker, his soul reflects strength or weakness. When a soul is pumped full of energy, it can correlate with an improvement in physical or mental ability, or it can burst out in unnatural psychic display. Except for the last case, the warp does not actually have to exist.

    Eldar are long lived, physically superior to humans, and their souls are strong. Tau have natural life spans shorter than humans', they can only do the jobs they are born into, and their souls are feeble. A person's soul is what he is, so adding to his body adds to his soul. Grafting organs with another person's genes onto a person's body, to the extent that a space marine is completely different from the person he would have been without those organs, means his life and his soul, whatever life he would have led on Fenris or Deliverance, are effectively overwritten by the significance of those organs. The space marine is an armature that holds up an occulobe and a biscopea, a substrate for the power of marine zygotes to make their mark in the world. A primarch's dna is doing the work, the aspirant is an amenuensis for a greater man.
    By this argument you are just an organic sockpuppet controlled by your ancestors.

    As such I can understand that you might not grasp that nowhere in the canon has it ever been stated that "pumping up" a soul makes the person more physically capable, there's plenty of examples of the warp being used to directly bolster perople mentally of physically but that's by effecting their real-space selves or affecting their soul/reflection in complex and inherently unsustainable ways (just look at what happened to the emperor when he stopped being able to sustain his 38,000 year old biomantic enhancement) not by simply placing more energy into their soul.

    What you describe is more like plugging someones brain into an electrical main to incease their brainpower using the reasoning "it's electric too."
    Quote Originally Posted by Spider-pope View Post
    Also, i think Askil should be hired by GW immediately and take over all future fluff development for 40k.
    Quote Originally Posted by blackcherry View Post
    I think this [...] goes to prove that if nothing else, Askil really should be in charge of the background for Chaos. He clearly gets just gets it.

  10. #50

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Askil the Undecided, can you edit/rephrase that. My comprehension skills are really struggling. I can't read the middle paragraph/sentence.
    Sent from my Astropath using Tele Talk

  11. #51
    Better than you Lothlanathorian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Solving Robot Ham's problems.
    Posts
    4,253

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by SomeRandomEvilGuy View Post
    Really? I thought in the comics, Captain America was supposed to be the best a human could physically be, whereas in the movies, he seems stronger than a human could be at that size. He tears hatches off and hurls people around one handed; I'm not sure a person could do the same.
    He does the same thing in the comics.
    ...............................This is a link to the Forum Rules.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,A Tale of Guilders plog
    Quote Originally Posted by salty View Post
    You people make baby Batman cry. And by cry, I mean punch people in the crotch. Because Batman doesn't cry. Ever. Not even baby Batman.
    Quote Originally Posted by Mannimarco View Post
    Arrogant egotistical insane sadomasochists do not make good team players.

  12. #52

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Xavier is already in warhammer 40k...

    But he goes by an alias... Gideon Ravenor....
    1850pts Imperial Guard
    Painted: Vendetta Gunship, 50 guardsmen, Marbo, 4 Chimeras, Manticore, Leman Russ, Valkyrie Carrier, 20 Veterans, 5 Ogryns.
    1750pts Blood Ravens
    Painted: 21 Assault, 10 Tactical Marines, 5 Terminators, Land Raider, Rhino
    Basecoated: 9 Assault, 5 Devastator Marines, Terminator Librarian
    Beyond The Gates of Antares

  13. #53

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by GodlessM View Post
    Good to see I'm not the only one that realises Cap predates GW Space Marines by more than 4 decades.



    No she really couldn't. Average car weighs 1000kg. The strongest man in the world under stress (i.e. with adrenaline already pumping through him) can lift 395kg. I tihink you can see what I'm getting at here. Simply put, adrenaline can only do so much, the ability has to exist in the first place.
    I took the kirby statements from earlier as a joke to be honest and I'm sure others did the same (honestly its nice to have someone give kirby some credit instead of just stan lee).

    As for the car example its a bit more complicated than that. Col. Tarleton's example was pulling a car off of someone, and while the whole car weights 2k, lifting a corner or pulling/pushing the vehicle would require a lot less strength.

    Quote Originally Posted by Lothlanathorian View Post
    He does the same thing in the comics.
    To an extent, I guess when I think of movie cap it isn't just avengers, its his movie as well. For me what makes movie cap stronger than comic cap is when he jumps across the building in his movie, which comic cap wouldn't have been capable of, granted I mainly stick with Brubakers run, so I could see other Authors having a different ideal of his power level.

  14. #54
    Better than you Lothlanathorian's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2005
    Location
    Solving Robot Ham's problems.
    Posts
    4,253

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    I'll give you that. Brubaker is the reason I like Cap these days.
    ...............................This is a link to the Forum Rules.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,A Tale of Guilders plog
    Quote Originally Posted by salty View Post
    You people make baby Batman cry. And by cry, I mean punch people in the crotch. Because Batman doesn't cry. Ever. Not even baby Batman.
    Quote Originally Posted by Mannimarco View Post
    Arrogant egotistical insane sadomasochists do not make good team players.

  15. #55
    Commander Carlosophy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Location
    Sheffield, UK
    Posts
    699

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by insectum7 View Post
    Heh. He wishes.
    Pfft. Captain America is an ideal few space marines can actually aspire to. Indoctrinated killing machines are basically what being an Astartes is all about. Even Dante and Calgar, such is their nobility would struggle to replicate the heroics or Cap.

    And I'd love to see a marine try to lift Thor's Hammer by himself!

  16. #56
    Chapter Master stormblade's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Location
    Holy Terra
    Posts
    1,321

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    He also somehow managies to be a bigger mary sue and a lamer piece of fiction than any marine (and this includes the smurfs) can even aspire to be.
    "WE ARE THE ONLY SOURCE OF GOODNESS, SEVERE AND DRASTIC. THERE IS NO OTHER SOURCE OF HOPE THAN US. WE ARE AGONISINGLY ALONE."
    beer and axes

  17. #57

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by althathir View Post
    As for the car example its a bit more complicated than that. Col. Tarleton's example was pulling a car off of someone, and while the whole car weights 2k, lifting a corner or pulling/pushing the vehicle would require a lot less strength.
    Exactly a lot of people are probably thinking that the woman would suddenly have superhuman strength or something like that and be able to flip the car over.
    Nothing could be further from the truth as you said pushing and pulling a car requires a lot less strength and nobody says you have to flip a car over, to get a person trapped underneath out.
    Just lifting it a few centimeters up can usually be more than enough to get the trapped person out and that short adrenaline boost should be more than enough for such a feat.
    Another thing adrenaline can also do is block of your pain receptors in your brain for a short time at least; there are several stories of mountaineers (amongst others) who suffers a horrible accident however at the time of the accident they felt no pain.
    Not until they were safe and within reach of medical help, did the pain start.
    Our body isnīt stupid, it knows well enough that if it instantly hits you with the agonizing pain you should be feeling right now, you probably wonīt be able to get yourself to safety and you would most likely die (something the body has no interest in).

    Actually while we on the topic I believe that it was one of these mechanisms that prompted Fabius Bile to start experimenting on his legion brothers.

    As for Wolverine i think the Space Wolves might make an exception him, remember the Fenrisians themselves arenīt completely human (or so it is hinted at in Thousand Sons, that the first settlers of Fenris got a little TOO friendly with gene modification) and Wolverine do shear alot of features similar to that of the Space wolves, including a rather bestial nature though his claws might prove a bit of a difference.
    While i remember i think Archangel might be considered for application in the Blood Angels as his only mutation is the same as the Primarchs (he got wings and thatīs it) and he isnīt exactly the first of the Blood Angels to grow wings....though in retrospect, that little incident didnīt turn out that well in the end all things considered.

  18. #58

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    Quote Originally Posted by Lothlanathorian
    He does the same thing in the comics.
    Fair enough. Seems a bit beyond human ability, at least at that size, but oh well.

  19. #59
    Chapter Master El_Machinae's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    a pale blue dot
    Posts
    3,354

    Re: Is Captain America basically a Space Marine?

    He's a bit beyond what we'd think reasonable for an exceptional human

    http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0...1tk0_super.jpg
    http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/0...2za5_super.jpg
    Pro-actively transhumanist and an Immortalist
    The fable of the dragon tyrant explains why. Text. Youtube.
    You and I have opportunity to create synergy

Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •