You might have noted that some people have already said that your method might apply to small tournaments. Then again, there have been many times where there have been bad calls at small tournaments. I haven't seen you admit that having a FAQ like the INAT will greatly help reduce the chance or the severity of rules arguments at any tournament. Again, as Theocraxcity noted, using the FAQ will scale down from a large to a small tournament, but your method does not scale well at all to a larger tournament. I do have a question - are you the only judge at your tournaments? I can see many more problems with your method once multiple judges get involved.