
Originally Posted by
Chivs
We? All? Some certainly. Many maybe. Majority? Who can say.
Anecdote:
On 40k's 25th anniversary I took part in a mashed together multiplayer Kill Team game in a GW store. One of the four players was using Codex: Witch Hunters. I'd completely forgotten that there'd been a White Dwarf article for Sisters of Battle anyway, and noone raised an eye at using an 'Out of date' codex. Halfway through the game the player wanted to use his Vindicare assassin. I pointed out that the Vindicare could fire into close combat, and other players called foul at this. The staffer was called, and said that in Codex: Grey Knights the Vindicare assassin has changed and couldn't be used that way. I pointed out that we weren't using Grey Knights, but Witch Hunters (There are plenty of examples of Space Marine codices having the same equipment work different ways in different books). It was then the staffer said that Witch Hunters was out of date - we should be using Codex: Sisters of Battle.
Fair Enough. But when the young player said he missed those issues of White Dwarf and so couldn't use that codex, there was no suggestion of what he should do. There was no store copy produced that he could use, or even look through. While we did continue the game anyway, in essence a young player had been told that his rules were out of date, and then left to stand there. How is this acceptable?