I'm not cherry picking. I just feel that if you want the warhammer fluff to make any sense you probably have to stop at the point where it's still linear. You simply can't discuss warhammer fluff by incorperating the new material because the new material just goes back and forth between screw ups, with the next screw up trying to fix the previous one.
So you can either take the old fluff and have a discussion. Or take the new fluff and go around in circles because nothing adds up. Cherry picking or playing favorites has nothing to do with it.