got two as competitive as possible lists for LOTR conflict scotland and i want you to decide which is better. The missions are take the middle, a variant of kill the king (with all heroes worth a point) and a straight fight.

madril
faramir
18 rangers
16 warriors minas tirith with shields hand weapons
22 spearmen minas tirith with shields

or

beregond
damrod
11 rangers
20 knights minas tirith with shields
24 warriors minas tirith with shields

poll above, tactically advice below, cheers