View Poll Results: Would you like to see generic ward saves ignored from magical attacks?

Voters
66. You may not vote on this poll
  • Yes

    11 16.67%
  • No

    55 83.33%
Results 1 to 20 of 20

Thread: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

  1. #1

    Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Thinking this might make warhammer more interesting. All other forms of saves have a way to get through them so why not make ward saves the same way? Basically what would you think if all generic univeral ward saves were negated by magic? You could still keep conditional ward saves against whatever they are designed to protect against, but a universal ward save would be negated by magic. This would make demons more managable and make Pheonix Guard less annoying. Any comments or ideas how this could mess up the game? Or thoughts on how this would effect the game?
    2010 Tournament Record W/L/D
    Warriors of Chaos (Dragon Ogre Theme) 2/0/1
    Chaos Space Marines (Emperors Children) 0/2/2

  2. #2
    Chapter Master Neknoh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    7,553

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    It would also make a lot of items overpriced and squew the costing of the Treespirit Wardsave. It is good as is, the bad thing was to make Daemons of Chaos get a generic wardsave instead of a Daemonic one which they used to have.
    Fleets of steampunk airships need playtesting; Above the Seven Seas andSteamflight Games - the, now official, website of Above the Seven Seas
    Cross of Roses ANOTHER system? You ask... yes, I am that mad, thisone will be skirmish-sized

    The Dark Fae, my Warriors of Chaos army with a different theme than normal. Updated 28/2 09

  3. #3
    Chapter Master Lord Malorne's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Gargaron, kingdom of teh Crabz0rs
    Posts
    6,640

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    I play wood elves and having a magic useless ward save sucks.

    Neknoh:The DoC had a real ward save in the storm of chaos book as Daemonic leagions or whatever, I agree that they should sufer the wrath of magic without a save though...damn magical beings.

  4. #4
    Chapter Master Neknoh's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Posts
    7,553

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    I know fully well that they had it, I played them allong with Archaon's Horde. The problem was that allready there, we saw tendencies for silly things... and GW seem to have ignored said tendencies or simply didn't remember them
    Fleets of steampunk airships need playtesting; Above the Seven Seas andSteamflight Games - the, now official, website of Above the Seven Seas
    Cross of Roses ANOTHER system? You ask... yes, I am that mad, thisone will be skirmish-sized

    The Dark Fae, my Warriors of Chaos army with a different theme than normal. Updated 28/2 09

  5. #5
    Librarian SuperArchMegalon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Seattle, WA
    Posts
    404

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    That would make taking a ward save on a character really useless - especially a character like a Thane with 4+ ward save, designed for just soaking up wounds from enemy characters.

  6. #6
    Chapter Master badgeraddict's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2007
    Location
    Ipswich, Suffolk
    Posts
    1,002

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Simply No.

    I am quite happy with the current rules for generic ward saves, and I like my Bretonnian ward saves to much.

    'nuff said.
    "You are cordially invited to 'The Congress of Vienna'. Music by Beethoven & Ultravox. Dress Military Casual."
    Quote Originally Posted by only joking... View Post
    I would happily take home the award but since you set your leg on fire...Maybe not.

  7. #7
    Chapter Master Oberon's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2005
    Location
    The Grimm Darggness of Far Future
    Posts
    2,244

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    It would be like "fixing" high elves by giving all of them ASF, or something. "Fixing" something that isn't quite balanced, by changing the whole rule, that affects other armies too, that are not broken.

    No.
    -"Zeal and fury are rewarded with victory!"

    Quote Originally Posted by Lijacote View Post
    I find your arguments compelling and your literate expression so enticing that I must ask myself to be added to the list of subscribers entitled to receive scheduled packets of gold in the form of your argumentative genius.
    Quote Originally Posted by Takitron View Post
    They know how they want you to play the game, they just cant be arsed to tell you.

  8. #8
    Chapter Master
    Join Date
    Dec 2007
    Posts
    1,222

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    more magic missiles? no thanks.

  9. #9
    Chapter Master theunwantedbeing's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    Preston,in my house.
    Posts
    13,201

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    I say we remove magical items.
    And magic.
    And any army that isnt empire or bretonnians.

    There we go, warhammer is saved

    Seriously though....

    Ward saves arent overpowered.
    Sure the DE one you have trouble with, but then again thats you own silly fault for hitting him with st5+ things, or for that matter actually hitting him in the first place. The rest of the army is t3 with a 2+ save at best (more likely 5+/4+) hit them instead!
    Also with daemons, yes its annoying.....would be nice to see normal daemons only get a true ward save by being joined by a herald of their god, or by being within 6"(or maybe 12") of a greater daemon of the same god though.
    Maybe next time eh?

    I bet those are the 2 real reasons you want ward saves all nerfed to hell.
    Maybe the bretonnian ward save too...that 6+ ward has saved far too many knights from an arrowey doom...

    It would weaken the ward save far too much though, magic missles are very common and plenty can kill the enemy character if they arent getting their ward save. Seems too good to be true really.
    As a dark elf player it's more for my opponents sake....dark elves can do a seriously large amount of magical damage, far too good if the enemy never got their ward saves. I personally never use the pendant, I dont need a ward save when the other guy never gets to hit my character's :P
    Last edited by theunwantedbeing; 18-02-2009 at 15:39.
    Plan B kill it with fire
    Meat is Murder tasty, tasty murder
    Quote Originally Posted by RanaldLoec View Post
    I would have to agree with The Unwantedbeing as he is a paragon of sense and reason in an unreasonable environment.

  10. #10
    Chapter Master Desert Rain's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Lund, Sweden
    Posts
    2,840

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Simply no. It would nerf every ward save giving item in the game. 'Nuff said.
    Hear now the dirge faint reprised,
    before the sun's fall, this day spills red
    on buckled earth, and in obsidian eyes
    vengeance chimes seven times


    Visit my High Elves painting log

  11. #11
    Commander Leth Shyish'phak's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    The Chaos Wastes
    Posts
    699

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    What about giving magical attacks the chance to modify ward saves in the same way as they would to armour saves?
    I've just finished a rewrite of Codex: Dark Angels for 6th edition! Find it here:

    http://www.warseer.com/forums/showth...ex-Dark-Angels

  12. #12
    Chapter Master The SkaerKrow's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Columbus, Ohio
    Posts
    2,185

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Magic is already powerful enough, it doesn't need to be made moreso by giving it some strange ability to pierce Ward saves.
    Khorne Dogs, Khorned Beef, Khreamed Khorne, Khorne Chips, Khornemeal Muffins, Popkhorne, Khorne Flakes, Khorne Bread, Khornish Hens, Khorne Syrup, Khandy Khorne, Khorne on the Khob...

    -The Ultimate Mono-Khorne (Grocery) List

    Jagdmacht, my Imperial Guard Project Log

  13. #13
    Commander
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    709

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    No, ward saves need to be left alone. I don't even have a problem with teh Daemon ward save, the units just need to be costed appropriately. Ward saves are not a problem, it is the cost of those ward saves that need to be examined. You also shouldn't have them modified by magic because most ward saves are already pretty low, 5+ or 6+.

  14. #14
    Chapter Master
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    1,316

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    No just because they had no idea what they were doing when they wrote Demons and High Elves doesn't mean that everyone else should suffer. Often times the ward is the only thing keeping you alive from magic attacks.

    Of course the proliferation of these silly 2+/3+/ 4+ ward saves needs to stop. It's getting ridiculous.

  15. #15
    Chapter Master Bac5665's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Columbus, Ohio
    Posts
    1,542

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Gods no.

    Ward saves on characters are there to stop enemy characters from killing your character. If magic weapons ignore the saves, than characters will have almost no defense most of the time. And that's no fun. The best character duels last multiple turns, not ending on the first round before on side even attacks.

  16. #16
    Banned
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Copenhagen, Denmark
    Posts
    2,527

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Nothing wrong with ward saves. The DE 2+ save is might a bit too much, but it is only one man.

    Dumping the daemonic rule for daemons ward saves was a bit silly (they could just have had their characters buy proper ward saves), but the whole thing screwed up the balance between ethereals, forest spirits and daemons, and even worse it caused the magical attack ability to become obsolete (even nerfing daemons).

    But you need the ability to protect your general from harm, otherwise we'll just end up with a sad lot of wizards to lead the armies instead of brave and heroic fighters

  17. #17
    Chapter Master MalusCalibur's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Posts
    1,197

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    A thousand times no. As many have already stated, there is no need for magic to become any more potent, and Ward Saves in general are not a problem. Not even Daemons, because with a 'negated by magic' save, their infantry becomes fragile and overpriced, just like it was back in the old HoC book. And we all know how many players seriously took Daemonic infantry back then...


    MalusCalibur
    Quote Originally Posted by Lord_Byron View Post
    I'd have to say that I hate the Ogre Kingdoms Scraplauncher the most. Not because it's ugly, but because you need to have a masters degree in civil engineering, four hands, and the patience of Ghandi to put one together evenly...
    My Fantasy Project Log
    My Sci-Fi Project Log

  18. #18
    Commander IrishDelinquent's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Oshawa, Ontario
    Posts
    502

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    I agree with everyone else that ward saves are fine the way they are. By allowing magical attacks to negate ward saves, you screw over certain armies and units (wardancers, Savage Orcs, Daemons), and army lists would rely on cramming as many casters in as possible (and Thorek Ironbrow would become even more hated).
    Quote Originally Posted by Malice&Mizery View Post
    Give this guy a bloody cookie! He just won the thread.
    Quote Originally Posted by Tzeentch Lover View Post
    "+3 ward save? Get in mah pants!"

  19. #19

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Quote Originally Posted by The SkaerKrow View Post
    Magic is already powerful enough, it doesn't need to be made moreso by giving it some strange ability to pierce Ward saves.
    No.

    Magic that isn't attacks is already powerful enough. Vaul's Unmaking, Danse, Raise, etc etc...

    Certain casters and one or two lists, are already powerful enough. Demonic Lore of Tzeentch, the ability to have like 6-7 casters in an army, etc...

    Magic as a whole, is gimped because of the millions of cheaper ways to stop it - unless you're facing VC or a ridic demon list.

  20. #20
    Chapter Master Dooks Dizzo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    1,519

    Re: Rule Proposal, All Generic Ward Saves Negated by Magic

    Generic as in Daemon? Yes.

    Generic as in magic item? Hell no.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •